FoodPlacee Passport United States · New York · 73374
Verified Vinny's Pizzeria
Croghan, New York, USA
Rating★ 4.8 / 5
Price$10–20
CategoryPizza Restaurant
Today 11:00 AM - 07:30 PM
Food Place Passport
Vinny's Pizzeria in New York
Discover Vinny's Pizzeria in Croghan, NY. Enjoy local specialty pizzas, dine-in or takeout, with great reviews, casual atmosphere, and convenient hours.
9786 NY-812, Croghan, NY 13327, United States
Overview
About This Food Place
Vinny's Pizzeria is a beloved pizza restaurant nestled in Croghan, NY, known for its authentic New York-style pizza and comforting menu selections. With a strong 4.8-star rating from 86 reviewers, this spot consistently delivers a cozy and quiet atmosphere ideal for both locals and visitors seeking a satisfying meal.
The menu highlights a blend of classic pizzas like Hawaiian and White Pizza alongside house specialties such as Spaghetti, Baked Ziti, and a variety of subs. Spacious seating and attentive table service complement its comfortable setting, making it a perfect choice for a quick bite or a relaxed lunch or dinner.
Gallery
Photos from Vinny's Pizzeria
Real shots of the food, atmosphere, and signature dishes at this location.
Local favorites
Why People Come Here
Vinny's Pizzeria draws pizza lovers seeking authentic flavors, quick service, and a welcoming environment in Croghan, NY.
Highly Rated Local Favorite
With an impressive 4.8-star rating from 86 reviews, the quality and flavor consistently impress visitors.
Local Specialty Dishes
Known for serving regional favorites like NY-style pizza and unique subs that keep guests coming back.
Quick Bite and Comfort Food
Perfect for a satisfying lunch or dinner, offering comfort food with fast and friendly service.
Family-Friendly & Group Dining
Accommodations for kids with a drinks menu and high chairs, plus a cozy spot ideal for groups and tourists.
Takeout and Dine-In Options
Convenient service options allow for enjoying dining on site or bringing favorite dishes home.
Accessible Parking and Amenities
Wheelchair accessible parking and restrooms ensure comfort for all visitors.
Warm, Casual Atmosphere
A quiet and cozy setting paired with friendly staff offers a relaxed dining experience.
Experience
When & How to Enjoy This Place
Ideal for those craving comfort food, Vinny’s offers flavorful Italian-American classics best enjoyed midday or early evening.
Guests typically spend anywhere from a brief 10 minutes to an hour and a half, whether grabbing a quick slice or savoring a full meal in a casual, welcoming environment. — FoodPlacee editorial note
Group Dinners
The spacious seating and friendly staff accommodate groups and families comfortably, making it a wonderful place to gather for dinner with friends or loved ones.
Takeout Convenience
Quick service and diverse menu options make takeout a convenient choice for a satisfying meal on the go, perfect for busy days or casual nights at home.
Lunch Breaks
Enjoy a hearty lunch featuring local specialties like the classic subs or pizza combos, ideal for solo diners or team outings during weekday service hours.
Tourist Stop
Located right on NY-812, this pizzeria welcomes tourists with comforting flavors reminiscent of New York’s pizza tradition, offering free parking for easy access.
Family-Friendly Eats
With a kids’ menu and high chairs available, families can enjoy a casual and cozy meal together without worry, accompanied by quick service and comfort food favorites.
Best for Groups Popular for Lunch Ideal for Dinner Takeout Available Free Parking Local Specialty Family Friendly Accessible Parking
Guest sentiment
What People Feel
A snapshot of what local diners frequently mention about this location.
JM
java mochafrap 3 week ago
"Had a chicken parm sandwich that tasted great. Crunchy bread, fresh chicken and good sauce. I was driving thru on my way back to NYC. Nice people working there."
CP
Christine Purpura 4 week ago
"Best pizza around! Vinny's pizza is an edible masterpiece. Their crispy crust combined with a deliciously flavored sauce and pefectly melted cheese is the way pizza should be. Ever bite is better than the last. The staff is friendly and welcoming and there is a truly family atmosphere there. I will gladly take the drive to visit Vinny's again."
IV
ITC Vapes 1 month ago
"The pizza and wings are decent but nothing to rave about. Typical local pizza joint quality. Definitely better than chain store pizza. The subs though! If you enjoy a good sub their bread alone makes it worth a try and would justify a 4.5 if it was an option. I suggest the croghan bologna!"
BM
Bonnie MacCartney 2 month ago
"They never miss. Always great. Top notch NY style pizza and excellent wings."
DB
Default Bandaid 2 month ago
"Best place in Lewis County to get pizza and calzones, by far. They even left a small piece of broccoli on my girlfriend’s calzone as garnish when we ordered two so that we knew them apart."
BS
Ben Sayre 2 month ago
"The pizza is great! Also got a meatball and cheese sub that was amazing! The sub roll was sooo soft yet held together and wasn't soggy when you get around to the 2nd half. They tasted freshly made in house!! Will be back often!"
LB
Lima Bravo 3 month ago
"Truly the best pizza that I have had in the North County. I could have imagined that I was back in the city, New York, of course.the crust was thin and not overworked, so the last piece was as light as the first. I would have liked a bit more sauce, but that is my preference. The cheese was a nice balance of mozzarella and parmesan, without too much saltiness. They even used ceramic plates and regular knives and forks. Buon appetito"
GB
Ginger Button 3 month ago
"This is the best pizza we have ever had. We have experienced great, good, and moderate to gross pizzas in our lives, (and we are not spring chickens) but this pizza surpassed them all! It was not greasy, the crust was crisp, without being burned, there was the perfect amount of sauce, spread out to the edges of the crust, and plentiful toppings. We will absolutely be back!"
Visit info
When to Visit
Weekly hours below — always confirm with the business before holidays or special events.
Today Closed
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11:00 AM - 07:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11:00 AM - 07:30 PM |
| Friday | 11:00 AM - 07:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11:00 AM - 07:30 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Hours may change. Please confirm with the business before visiting.
Best time to visit
Plan your visit on weekdays and Saturdays to enjoy lunch or dinner during Vinny's operating hours in Croghan.
Wednesday to Saturday: 11:00 AM - 7:30 PM Popular for Lunch & Dinner Great for Groups and Solo Dining Typical visit lasts 10 minutes to 1.5 hours Free parking available on-site and nearby
On the map
Where This Food Place Lives
Find your way to Vinny's Pizzeria in New York .
Address 9786 NY-812, Croghan, NY 13327, United States
Phone +1 315-346-1444
Area New York
Call Address copied ✓
Questions answered
Food Place Questions
Find answers to common questions about Vinny's Pizzeria, including menu options, dining experience, and accessibility.
Vinny's Pizzeria is open Wednesday through Saturday from 11:00 AM to 7:30 PM. The restaurant is closed on Sunday, Monday, and Tuesday. Hours may vary, so checking ahead is recommended.
Yes, both takeout and dine-in services are available. Guests can enjoy a casual and cozy atmosphere while dining or conveniently order food for takeout.
Payments can be made using credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for a smooth checkout experience.
The restaurant is good for kids and provides high chairs and a kids' menu to accommodate families comfortably.
Free parking is available both in the parking lot and on the street. The location also includes wheelchair accessible parking to support guests with mobility needs.
Menu selections include pizza combos, subs, house specialties, finger foods, salads, and hot subs. Popular items include the 1 Combo Pizza, Croghan Bologna sub, and Stuffed Shells. Menu items and availability may change.
Visitors usually spend anywhere from 10 minutes up to an hour and a half, depending on whether they are grabbing a quick bite or dining in.
Dogs are allowed outside, making it a pet-friendly option for those who want to bring their furry companions along.
Nearby brands
Related food places near Vinny's Pizzeria
Other casual restaurants and brands diners often visit in New York.
For owners
Own or manage this food place?
Update this page with accurate hours, menu details, photos, and business notes — and reach food lovers searching for places like yours on FoodPlacee.
Menus, prices, hours, services, and availability may change. Please contact the food place directly before visiting or ordering.